{"contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"joemyxter"}

United Airlines to charge fee to check single bag

UAL Corp's United Airlines on Thursday said it would begin charging its passengers $15 each way to check a single bag on domestic flights in an effort to offset soaring fuel prices.

{"contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"joemyxter"}
  • Enjoy this article? Help vote it up the 'Vine.
Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 ... 5
{"commentId":1946104,"authorDomain":"joemyxter"}

Do you think American and United will stick with the $15 first-bag fee? Will other airlines follow their lead, or will the move backfire and affect their customer base? Will the fees change the way you travel? Join the discussion.

{"commentId":1946104,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"joemyxter"}
  • 1 vote
Reply#1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:32 AM EDT
{"commentId":1946972,"authorDomain":"gopsux"}

Further proof that many corporations in the US can't afford to operate properly and instead seek out illegal activities like credit card companies instead of changing their business model.

{"commentId":1946972,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"gopsux"}
  • 1 vote
#1.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 1:16 PM EDT
{"commentId":1947532,"authorDomain":"swilliamlee"}

I think all airlines will move forward and start charging for bags sense they people loading them under the plane.
Due to the crises in the world in regards to gas cost, I've decided to park my Land Rover most of the time and get bike and a scooter also converting my land rover to also run on water.

I will cut back on my travel by 90% due to the cost and the sky's are longer friendly.

Paying cash for most things has been the norm for me for the past three years, but now even more. The money grubbing credit card companies are not going to get my money.

Currently cutting back on many things has become part of the daily job, it's now part of my like.

I'm seeking better deals even when I go out at night, what bars have the cheapest drinks gets my bucks.

I'm happier know how to survive this way.

{"commentId":1947532,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"swilliamlee"}
    #1.2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 2:19 PM EDT
    {"commentId":1948265,"authorDomain":"rbgus"}

    I will avoid those two airlines even though I have been a frequent flyer on both. By increasing the cost to the traveler they will have fewer passengers and have to further reduce costs - Use the WalMart model! Service is so poor from the airlines now, they are shooting themselves in the foot with increased charges and poorer service... $8.00 for a bottle of water?

    {"commentId":1948265,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"rbgus"}
      #1.3 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:39 PM EDT
      {"commentId":1948789,"authorDomain":"robertsbobisms"}

      Chargeing fees for checked bags was in progress with United Airlines back in December 2007, if you flew from Washington Dullas International So this is nothing new. As a matter of fact when asked about the practice, I was informed that the distinction for being the first to charge such a fee goes to Alaska Airlines. Will the charging of fees continue...yes! Why? Because members of our society have been stuck on stupid for so long...stupid has become the norm. If we only knew how marketing, advertising, information and disinformation, from reliable sources (such as the news channels) influenced us, we would realize how stupid and easily directed we truly are.

      {"commentId":1948789,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"robertsbobisms"}
        #1.4 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 4:34 PM EDT
        {"commentId":1949155,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

        Flying is a primary example that everything in this world doesn't have to be for everyone. When the airlines tried to make it affordable for every one they started losing money. The airlines need to charge whatever they need to become profitable. If you can't afford to fly, stay on the ground.

        {"commentId":1949155,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
        • 2 votes
        #1.5 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:18 PM EDT
        {"commentId":1950353,"authorDomain":"tang"}
        Further proof that many corporations in the US can't afford to operate properly and instead seek out illegal activities like credit card companies instead of changing their business model.

        What's illegal about charging for baggage? I don't like it, as a traveler, but it's not illegal.

        If you were king of United Airlines today, what *would* you do to change the business model in an attempt to bring the company back to profitability?

        {"commentId":1950353,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"tang"}
        • 2 votes
        #1.6 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 7:29 PM EDT
        {"commentId":1951550,"authorDomain":"philjhowe"}

        I think the fee will stick and other airlines will follow suit. The airlines are going to have to make up the shortfall somewhere! It will truly make people decide what they must take with them on their trip. I think that if you do your homework, buy far enough in advance (or be prepared to take a last-minute deal), flying can still be affordable and convenient. $15 is probably not going to break you since you're affluent enough to be flying. Just take comfort in the fact that in these situations a traveler with only a carry-on will no longer be subsidizing someone who has four checked bags! And those over-flowing luggage carts in the check-in line should become less common!

        {"commentId":1951550,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"philjhowe"}
          #1.7 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 9:44 PM EDT
          {"commentId":1980490,"authorDomain":"jmiccio"}

          Pity the already overstressed flight attendants! Tis the season of non-frequent flyers descending on airports with no clue as to travel do's & don'ts. I am sure the airlines will keep the costs, however, someone will have to manage the passenger cabins as more morons will bring overstuffed bags to cram into bins....all the while trying to balance down aisles with their lattes, softdrinks and picnics. All I can say is, if you are not a frequent flyer, be ready to have your bags checked! Happy Trails!

          {"commentId":1980490,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"jmiccio"}
            #1.8 - Mon Jun 16, 2008 5:14 PM EDT
            {"commentId":1981511,"authorDomain":"jgood-1"}

            I will try not to fly United or US Airways if I can possibly fly with another carrier

            {"commentId":1981511,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"jgood-1"}
              #1.9 - Mon Jun 16, 2008 7:56 PM EDT
              {"commentId":1992668,"authorDomain":"svaladi"}

              So what happens if our baggaes donot reach the destination? will the airlines pay back the charges? i n as much as wwe have to comply with their rules what about them sticking to the time. they are perenially delayed and their book of excuses seems to be a very big one? can penalties be levied on them for poor performance? will customers be paid back for their sloppy performance?

              {"commentId":1992668,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"svaladi"}
                #1.10 - Wed Jun 18, 2008 7:56 AM EDT
                Reply
                {"commentId":1946204,"authorDomain":"Serena7362"}

                All these airlines are doing is increasing the amount of carry on baggage that goes onto these planes, which make the cabins even more crowded. People are bringing on the absolute maximum allowed carry on, which doesnt always fit into the overhead bins due to over packing them or the odd shape which doesnt fit through the opening to the overhead bin. These same bags are then crowding the under seat storage and causing people to have less leg room themselves, or causing their "neighbors" to have less space. Bringing more carry on baggage is slowing down the safety check lines as well. It is obvious that these airlines do not care about customer service and take full advantage of a limited market! I understand about the rising gas prices, so just increase the airfare! Stop all of this a la carte pricing.

                {"commentId":1946204,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"Serena7362"}
                  Reply#2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:45 AM EDT
                  {"commentId":1946775,"authorDomain":"shoppingmarge"}

                  I agree with Serena - people are already taking too many carry-on bags, some oversized ... Maybe instead of charging to check a bag, the airlines should charge to carry on bags.

                  {"commentId":1946775,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"shoppingmarge"}
                  • 1 vote
                  #2.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:54 PM EDT
                  {"commentId":1949589,"authorDomain":"lhornreed"}

                  I can not remember which Airline but I do remember my purse being counted as a carry on. I placed my purse into my carry on, which was no more than a beach bag... I carried on one item!!
                  So maybe Maryanne has a point, but there would still be that fine line of what constitutes a carry on, vs. a laptop, large purse or make-up bag!!

                  {"commentId":1949589,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"lhornreed"}
                    #2.2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 6:07 PM EDT
                    Reply
                    {"commentId":1946228,"authorDomain":"ksmarkola"}

                    American and United shouldn't count on the millions of dollars they think they will make from this new fee. Gas prices along with general increases in everything are affecting everyone, not just the airline industry. As a result, less people will travel. Also, the higher you raise the price for less service (such as meals, checking baggage, etc.), the smaller customer base you are going to retain.

                    {"commentId":1946228,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"ksmarkola"}
                      Reply#3 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:49 AM EDT
                      {"commentId":1946242,"authorDomain":"debuha"}

                      not only will it will stay and increase, but all airlines will adopt and then they will raise second bag fee.i have been travel agent 23 years. they thought once they got rid of paying travel agents commission they would be on the world and it seems to me they just have a money handeling problem.

                      {"commentId":1946242,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"debuha"}
                        Reply#4 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:49 AM EDT
                        {"commentId":1946260,"authorDomain":"tony32244"}

                        when I began my career as a service tech 12 years ago, I began to notice then airlines are sticking it to business travellers, and it is only getting worse. I , like many others have a favored airline, but with the way things are going, my loyalties are going out the window. The right thing to do would be to charge more for the tickets. Then the lines would be shorter, less bobbleheads clogging the system and orbitz and others would go away.The give away pricing ruins any flight with first time and unknowing people who cause the delays and problems. Let them fly southwest and have a cattle call boarding. Many of us have had a 14 hour day already and have lost our patience.

                        {"commentId":1946260,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"tony32244"}
                          Reply#5 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:53 AM EDT
                          {"commentId":1946278,"authorDomain":"johnlinn007"}

                          I think its great that the airlines are charging for lots of things---no-one needs all the crap they try to take on their trips--also this could limit the slimy group of people who fly today--once limited to the bus-now airlines are so cheap that any o ne can use them--i hope it gets so expensive that only business people going on really useful trips and wealthy can fly--that way next trip i take i wont have to sit next to five sneezing slobering slugs who should be at home de-licing themselves

                          {"commentId":1946278,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"johnlinn007"}
                            Reply#6 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:54 AM EDT
                            {"commentId":1946280,"authorDomain":"it2leroyusn"}

                            The fee for the first-bag is ridiculous! I can see the fee for 2 or more bags or heavy items but for a FIRST BAG??? Come on now! Let's get real here! The Public needs at least one bag so they can carry a fresh change of clothes and toiletries! I have an ideal, how about the PUBLIC/American consumer CHARGING the U.S. Airline Industry for 'bumping' passengers when they (the airlines) are Overbooked, for travel delays, missed flights due to the airlines fault, strikes by their Unions and any other incidentals considered to be at the airlines fault!! I consider this a reasonable fee for the airline industry for screwing up peoples travel/vacation plans!!! FAIR is FAIR!!!

                            {"commentId":1946280,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"it2leroyusn"}
                              Reply#7 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 11:54 AM EDT
                              {"commentId":1946383,"authorDomain":"mzmomm"}

                              As far as I am concerned the Airlines can kiss my A$$! There service is crap compared to 10 or so years ago, they nickle and dime you for every little thing...surprised they do not charge you to pee too! Furthermore they are ALWAYS late cause they can't seem to pull their head out from their A$$ as they are too busy running around the terminal trying to fill one or two seats with the overflow, last flight was an hour and half late due to exactly this and I watched them intently the whole time. If the seat is sold and paid for, and someone doesn't show you punish everyone who did show trying to fill that seat...STUPID!!!! The fee that really torches my butt is the unaccompanied minor fee for which all the airline does is escort your child to their seat then off the plane to the appointed person for Continental to the tune of $75.00 each way. Guess my daughter will not be visiting her father any time in the near future...thank you to all the Airlines for being detrimental to my daughters relationship with her dad! I hope you all suffer and then have too re-evaluate your "customer service" which is nill.

                              {"commentId":1946383,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"mzmomm"}
                                Reply#8 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:07 PM EDT
                                {"commentId":1997126,"authorDomain":"firemedic258"}

                                Most of us agree that these fees suck, although we understand that the airlines are hurting because of fuel prices, the same as we are. What bothers most of us is the constant nickel and diming. If they need to raise fares, then do so.

                                However, it is unfair to blame the airlines if your child's relationship with her father suffers. If you and the father of your child choose to live that far apart that air travel is necessary, how are the airlines to blame for a poor relationship between your child and her father? You can't blame them for your choices in life. What type of values are you trying to teach your daughter for God's sakes? It's always someone else's fault? Thanks, we need more of those in America.

                                {"commentId":1997126,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"firemedic258"}
                                • 1 vote
                                #8.1 - Wed Jun 18, 2008 4:18 PM EDT
                                Reply
                                {"commentId":1946420,"authorDomain":"billpesnell"}

                                I agree with Deborah 319612, it's a management issue. Greed or profiteering. When I started in the business, airlines paid 10% of the base fare to agencies. No longer. But what they don't understand is that no carrier is prepared or manned to handle the business travel professionals push their way. It's sad. I'm not sure how the smaller agencies are staying in business. Next thing you know, they are going to charge you to go to the bathroom, and an extra elevated fee for each square of toilet paper! What will they do when people simply cut back on travel and the all go bankrupt? With today's technology, business meetings can easily be held with online meeting sites, thereby cutting out the need (so much) to fly. It's like don't poop where you eat! But they already have.

                                {"commentId":1946420,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"billpesnell"}
                                  Reply#9 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:11 PM EDT
                                  {"commentId":1947853,"authorDomain":"goldendolphin2002"}

                                  im confused i flew within this last week on united and they sure are charging more than $25 to check in a second bag and if weighs more than 50 lbs. my mouth hit the floor when i seen it was $100 for the second bag and $100 if it weighed more than 50lbs. i was thankful that i only brought 1 bag. i also agree about the carry ons it was crowed in the overhead storage that i was thankful that all i had was my purse and camcorder to fit under the seat. where does the madness end????

                                  {"commentId":1947853,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"goldendolphin2002"}
                                    #9.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 2:53 PM EDT
                                    Reply
                                    {"commentId":1946442,"authorDomain":"dhud78"}

                                    This is just another way for the executives to pocket more money in revenue. They have raised ticket prices to cover their fuel costs. Why does Southwest not do these extra fees. The answer better management. I heard this morning SW bought futures in gas when a barrel of oil was $59. Smart thinking. So all these other fees the other airlines are charging are totally ludicrous. So the more carry on we have the more the cabin becomes unsafe if the flight hits turbulence and the doors open and the longer we now have to sit on the plane why they take these extra cases off to store them in the cargo hold. Hmm now there's a thought you don't pay at the counter and they store the bag under the cargo hold for free, like they should be doing anyway. Just another fleecing of America...Thank you Our elected senators and environmental wackoes. Remember BIG BROTHER is gaining strength

                                    {"commentId":1946442,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"dhud78"}
                                      Reply#10 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:14 PM EDT
                                      {"commentId":1946614,"authorDomain":"shatteredandtorn"}

                                      Southwest did buy oil at one time for $59.00 a barrel but that has run out. Southwest has raised prices as of late and also has been caught for safety violations numerous times. Remember you pay for what you get...Until the government takes back over the airline industry it will not get better. Its amazing how Singapore, Cathay Pacific, Air Canada and Emirates Airlines do not have these problems. Just the other day while flying on American the flight attendant tried to make me close the overhead bin because it wasn't there job anymore to do it. Since I did not use it I told her I was not closing it. She almost freaked until she realized that I was Executive Platinum then her story changed immediately. US Airlines are a disgrace!!!!!!

                                      {"commentId":1946614,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"shatteredandtorn"}
                                        #10.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:35 PM EDT
                                        Reply
                                        {"commentId":1946447,"authorDomain":"cmccormick"}

                                        I feel that everyone is hurting right now due to the fuel prices not just the airlines. Everyone has at least one bag to check in so we shouldn't be penalized. The people they should charge is the passengers that don't check in their bags and put them in the overhead bins. Let's go back to the old days where all bags are checked. This will speed up the process of passengers getting on/off plane.

                                        {"commentId":1946447,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"cmccormick"}
                                          Reply#11 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:15 PM EDT
                                          {"commentId":1946462,"authorDomain":"richardschaney"}

                                          While I understand the airlines plight, they need to understand ours. Airline fares have almost tripled in the past month. The public's gasoline prices are now over $4.00 gallon. The public is certainly not going to pay the sky high airline ticket fees along with luggage fees and maybe lavatory fees. We are going to curtail our driving on long trips. All I can see is airline travel declining due to cost. What don't their bean counters understand about disposable income. I was once a veteran flier but not anymore.
                                          Goodbye the friendly skies. Most of you had lousy service anyway.

                                          {"commentId":1946462,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"richardschaney"}
                                            Reply#12 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:17 PM EDT
                                            {"commentId":1946495,"authorDomain":"joes187det"}

                                            I Totally agree with Serena7362. people with carry ons, backpacks etc. crowd the cabins, hold up de-planeing and are usually very rude. Charge for the carry-ons!! With less carry-ons going through security cheks will be faster and easier.

                                            {"commentId":1946495,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"joes187det"}
                                              Reply#13 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:20 PM EDT
                                              {"commentId":1946511,"authorDomain":"it2leroyusn"}

                                              This is ridiculous! The PUBLIC needs at least one BAG so they can carry their clothing, toiletries when they travel on business or on a vacation!! I agree with a second bag fee or more or for heavy items. I suggest to all who are reading this post to write their Congressman/Congresswoman, the Airlines Industry, CEO'S, and any others involved in the airline industry that ENOUGH is ENOUGH with these outrageous FEES!!! I have an ideal, how about if the American Consumer/Public start CHARGING the AIRLINE INDUSTRY for MISSED FLIGHTS, OVERBOOKING, DELAYS, UNION STRIKES and other incidentals due to the FAULT of the Airline Industry itself and NOT from the Publics fault!!! I believe this a FAIR and REASONABLE charge!!! FAIR is FAIR!!! RIGHT??? Let us, the AMERICAN CONSUMER and the one's who are PAYING the Airlines BILLS, CEO'S outrageous Salaries/Bonuses start CHARGING the Airline Industry for Missed Flights, Overbooking, Delays, Union Strikes, etc.etc. and see how THEY (the Airline Industry) like it when the 'cards are turned on them'!!! OR, YOU the AMERICAN PUBLIC can just sit back and be lead like meek sheep and be led by the nose by the airline industry because they know you won't fight back because YOU need them more then they need you! Sooooooooo, either sit back and enjoy the increased FEES (errr..the 'ride') or START FIGHTING BACK people!!!

                                              {"commentId":1946511,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"it2leroyusn"}
                                                Reply#14 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:22 PM EDT
                                                {"commentId":1946515,"authorDomain":"kdupee"}

                                                This is ridiculous. Don't nickel and dime people to death, it is irritating. If the airlines need to raise fares a bit to offset fuel prices, then do it. Customers want to see the full price of a ticket at the time they buy a ticket and compare it to other airlines, not pick a fare and buy a ticket only to find out later there are additional fees. This policy would cost $50 round-trip to bring a kid's car seat, a pair of skis, or other items which passengers cannot leave home by packing lightly. Tell me the full fare the when I am comparing ticket options, and then don't ask me for more money later. Otherwise I will fly with an airline that has transparent pricing.

                                                {"commentId":1946515,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kdupee"}
                                                  Reply#15 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:23 PM EDT
                                                  {"commentId":1949263,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

                                                  I agree. Price the ticket to make a profit. If you can't afford to fly, stay on the ground.

                                                  {"commentId":1949263,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
                                                  • 1 vote
                                                  #15.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:32 PM EDT
                                                  {"commentId":1997156,"authorDomain":"firemedic258"}

                                                  There should be absolutely NO COST for checking a car seat. The airlines shouldn't penalize a person for trying to do the responsible thing regarding child safety.

                                                  {"commentId":1997156,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"firemedic258"}
                                                    #15.2 - Wed Jun 18, 2008 4:21 PM EDT
                                                    Reply
                                                    {"commentId":1946551,"authorDomain":"richardschaney"}

                                                    Place your seatbacks in their original upright position, turn off all electronic devices and fasten your seatbelt. Also pray that your 100# carry-on doesn't fall our of the over-loaded overhead bin.

                                                    Carry-on baggage has become absolutely ridiculous in the past decade.

                                                    {"commentId":1946551,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"richardschaney"}
                                                      Reply#16 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:27 PM EDT
                                                      {"commentId":1946560,"authorDomain":"musicfan3101"}

                                                      I believe that this was done because of the lawsuit that the skycaps had filed against one of the airlines(American?) recently and won. The skycaps were and are losing out on tips for a number of years now. To add $15 for the first checked bag on top of the $25 for a second checked bag, is ridiculous! I am an over-packer, aka "packing diva", however, I managed to consildate my stuff into one checked bag. Delta has a $3 per bag checked policy right now. I still checked with the skycaps, and paid the fee and tipped them too. I still feel that they do a good job and are not paid enough to get by in these tough economic times. I know that I will not be able to bring everything that I would normally travel with with my carryon. I may consider mailing my stuff to my destination, when not traveling to a hotel or resort. This is going to be kaos!

                                                      {"commentId":1946560,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"musicfan3101"}
                                                        Reply#17 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:28 PM EDT
                                                        {"commentId":1946593,"authorDomain":"brunbec123"}

                                                        The "nickel-and-dime" attitude of the airline industries is definitely turning off this travel lover!!! Instead of searching for airline ticket bargains, I will start looking for (stay loyal to) airlines that try to cater to their customers, if even in small ways. While I have often bought the lowest-priced ticket in the past, I will now be more inclined to pay a bit extra (perhaps $15) per ticket to avoid United and its $15 checked bag fee. I know I'll still shell out the same amount of money for the trip, but I certainly don't want to encourage this trend toward a la carte travel. I sincerely hope that other airline carriers (including AirTran, my current favorite) resist this trend.

                                                        {"commentId":1946593,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"brunbec123"}
                                                          Reply#18 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:33 PM EDT
                                                          {"commentId":1946643,"authorDomain":"william-johnston"}

                                                          Seeing that I just flew United to and from L.A. and paid $25 because I had a 2nd bag, I find this at the very least amusing. As I returned home last night I found out that I had paid $25 for the "PRIVILEDGE" to have United in fact lose the very bag I paid them extra for on my return trip. And they wonder how their customer service ratings are below virtually any other industry.

                                                          {"commentId":1946643,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"william-johnston"}
                                                          • 1 vote
                                                          Reply#19 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:38 PM EDT
                                                          {"commentId":1946661,"authorDomain":"matt-ramsey"}

                                                          The airlines are simply catering to the business traveler by making it cost extra to check a bag. More power to you, if people will pay it, then charge it. I think business travelers will start cutting back soon as well, so I think the strategy is flawed. They need to start charging what they need to make a profit and let the market fall where it will. First they make the seats smaller, then they cut out snacks, now charging for luggage. Sounds to me like they are desperate. I am voting with my wallet and will not be flying on leisure this year (except for free tickets from miles).

                                                          {"commentId":1946661,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"matt-ramsey"}
                                                            Reply#20 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:40 PM EDT
                                                            {"commentId":1948172,"authorDomain":"tkeller"}

                                                            Excellent comment about voting with your wallet and not flying for pleasure this year. It's getting to where I don't even want to fly for business let alone on my time off!

                                                            {"commentId":1948172,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"tkeller"}
                                                              #20.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 3:28 PM EDT
                                                              {"commentId":1949290,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

                                                              Great Idea. Pay or Stay.

                                                              {"commentId":1949290,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
                                                              • 1 vote
                                                              #20.2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:35 PM EDT
                                                              {"commentId":2151845,"authorDomain":"michaeltodd"}

                                                              Except frequent business travelers fly often enough to have Elite status and are exempt from most if not all of these fees.

                                                              For those of you who said to raise fares - they are. Transporting all of your crap is part of the cost, and they chose to target that cost (which is part of your fare) specifically, since more baggage = more fuel burned, more handling costs, more infrastructure, etc. I tend to think that in reality, they don't want the extra $$, they're just tired of being overburdened by having to load, transport and unload everyone's crap. The average adult passenger now weights 187 pounds (yes, average adult - men AND women) and if they are each bringing 50+ pounds of luggage, it's over 20% of the weight they're paying to have transported from point A to point B. $15 is a small portion of the average plane ticket, and for all of you Einstein's who say to ship your stuff ahead of time - good luck getting even second-day air for less than several hundred dollars for a 50-lb package. Even 3-5 day UPS ground for that amount of weight is going to cost considerably more than $15.

                                                              Since the occasional traveler tends to bring 2-3x more stuff than they actually NEED on a trip, the cost of checking bags will hopefully result in a decrease of the number of bags being traveled with in GENERAL (checked OR carried on) and therefore result in better service in baggage handling overall, etc.

                                                              {"commentId":2151845,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"michaeltodd"}
                                                                #20.3 - Wed Jul 9, 2008 3:09 PM EDT
                                                                Reply
                                                                {"commentId":1946708,"authorDomain":"angie-som"}

                                                                Maybe next they'll add a coin slot on the restroom door so you have to pay to use the facilities in-flight!

                                                                {"commentId":1946708,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"angie-som"}
                                                                  Reply#21 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:46 PM EDT
                                                                  {"commentId":1947227,"authorDomain":"lhornreed"}

                                                                  I thought they made 'coin' toilets illegal in the states! Are we paying to fly or to use a public toilet on the streets of New York City??

                                                                  {"commentId":1947227,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"lhornreed"}
                                                                    #21.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 1:45 PM EDT
                                                                    {"commentId":1949416,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

                                                                    If that's what it takes to make a profit, go fo it!

                                                                    {"commentId":1949416,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
                                                                    • 1 vote
                                                                    #21.2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:47 PM EDT
                                                                    Reply
                                                                    {"commentId":1946745,"authorDomain":"irene-watson3"}

                                                                    Charging for checked bags will only encourage more carry-ons. The airlines are insane. They should charge for oversized/overweight carry-on bags instead and allow one checked bag free.

                                                                    They should also enforce the rule that your carry on must be in the compartment DIRECTLY OVER YOUR SEAT. Too many times I've seen inconsiderate people seated at the back of the plane put their bag in the overhead at the front so they can grab and go.

                                                                    {"commentId":1946745,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"irene-watson3"}
                                                                      Reply#22 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:50 PM EDT
                                                                      {"commentId":1946751,"authorDomain":"carterre"}

                                                                      If the airlines are going to charge for checking the bag, then the airlines had better take better care of checked baggage and not lose them. In a step further I think the airlines should be held responsible for ALL lost bags and ALL stolen items from those bags

                                                                      {"commentId":1946751,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"carterre"}
                                                                        Reply#23 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:51 PM EDT
                                                                        Reply
                                                                        {"commentId":1946754,"authorDomain":"dcarverjr1"}

                                                                        While i agree with most of you on this forum, what kills me is most people will complain about the fees, complain about the fares, complain about the service, complain complain complain. Yet you will all still buy the tickets, pay the fees, continue to be their platinum fliers, and support exactly what they are doing. Stop complaining about it and stop flying United and American and any other airline that imposes fees such as a fee for any checked bag. There are plenty of airlines that don't a la carte travel. Bottom line...stop complaining and do something about it.

                                                                        {"commentId":1946754,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"dcarverjr1"}
                                                                        • 1 vote
                                                                        Reply#24 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:51 PM EDT
                                                                        {"commentId":1949336,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

                                                                        These airlines have the right to make as much as they can. Are any of you giving back any of your paycheck because you think you are making too much. It's called free enterprise. Make what you can. If you don't want to pay the price, don't. STAY ON THE GROUND!!

                                                                        {"commentId":1949336,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
                                                                        • 1 vote
                                                                        #24.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:39 PM EDT
                                                                        Reply
                                                                        {"commentId":1946786,"authorDomain":"kippmorrill"}

                                                                        United Airlines expects to make how much a year on this birdbrained idea? They forget that they need passengers to make this work. I will NEVER fly United again.......

                                                                        {"commentId":1946786,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kippmorrill"}
                                                                          Reply#25 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 12:55 PM EDT
                                                                          {"commentId":1949405,"authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}

                                                                          When they can't fly full planes and make a profit, they need to park planes til they can run them full and at a profit. Flying on a plane is not a God given right, it's a luxury. Stay on the ground if you can't afford the ticket.

                                                                          {"commentId":1949405,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"kennesawmc"}
                                                                          • 1 vote
                                                                          #25.1 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 5:45 PM EDT
                                                                          {"commentId":1951584,"authorDomain":"mzmomm"}

                                                                          For some people it is not a matter of paying for a service, it is whether or not the service it adequately supplied. Where the airlines are concerned the service is about the worst of any industry in the "free enterprise" profit society! Hence NO SERVICE PROVIDED...NO PROFIT DESERVED!

                                                                          {"commentId":1951584,"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454","authorDomain":"mzmomm"}
                                                                            #25.2 - Thu Jun 12, 2008 9:47 PM EDT
                                                                            Reply
                                                                            Jump to discussion page: 1 2 3 ... 5
                                                                            {"canLink":false,"threadId":"286890","isPrivate":false}
                                                                            Leave a Comment:
                                                                            You're in Easy Mode. If you prefer, you can use XHTML Mode instead.
                                                                            As a new user, you may notice a few temporary content restrictions. Click here for more info.
                                                                            {"threadId":"286890","contentId":"1566454"}
                                                                            Start TrackingStart Tracking
                                                                            Stop TrackingStop Tracking
                                                                            RSS feedSyndicate this contentRecent Articles & Seeds
                                                                            Joe Myxter's Latest Comments
                                                                            Joe Myxter's Recent Votes
                                                                            Joe Myxter has not voted for any articles or seeds yet.
                                                                            Comments & Feedback